Interverband für Rettungswesen logo

Christoph Schöni, Managing Director, sanasolutio GmbH, on behalf of the Interverband für Rettungswesen IVR«With BrainE4, and thanks to it, we were able to bring every organisation on board.»

No data, no tariff. And that is exactly the data that is missing: until now, Switzerland’s 101 ambulance services have collected their figures regionally and canton by canton, never in a uniform way. Christoph Schöni, Managing Director of sanasolutio GmbH, was tasked by the association of ambulance services with laying the groundwork for a new tariff. He feared that in the end the sector would deliver nothing. Without a data basis, it is hard even to negotiate with the accident insurers. His solution: listen first, then collect the data. With BrainE4, he asked the sector what it would take for them to disclose their figures. 70% took part in the idea duel and brought clarity. In this interview, Schöni explains what it gave him.
Christoph Schöni, Managing Director, sanasolutio GmbH, on behalf of the Interverband für Rettungswesen IVR

Mr Schöni, in what capacity did you work with BrainE4?

I have my own company that supports healthcare institutions. I have worked in healthcare for more than 25 years, mainly where tariffs are concerned, in other words how services are reimbursed. I hold the mandate from the IVR, the Swiss association of ambulance services, to lead the project on behalf of the ambulance services. So my work with BrainE4 was done under that mandate for the IVR and the Swiss ambulance services.

New tariffs for the ambulance services are on the way. What challenge did you want to solve with this dialogue?

I need to go back a little. In our healthcare system, you need data if you want to develop a tariff. Service providers are legally obliged to make this data available. In the ambulance sector, however, this has so far been handled very regionally and canton by canton, and the data was never collected nationally in a uniform way. There were considerable concerns and fears that in the end the ambulance services would deliver nothing. Without a data basis, it is difficult to develop a data-based tariff and then negotiate it with the accident insurers. That is why we wanted to address those fears: What do the ambulance services think, where are the possible stumbling blocks, and how do we need to proceed so that the data really comes in?
«You can go in, do an idea duel, leave, and come back a week later.»

So the aim was to prepare the ground for the data collection. Who exactly did you want to reach with the idea duel, and what was the most concrete goal?

The target group was the 101 ambulance services in Switzerland that hold a mandate from the cantons to provide emergency medical services. The goal was to design the data collection so well that the actual survey would achieve the highest possible response rate.

You asked the sector under what conditions it would disclose its own figures. Was that the decisive question for you?

It was one of the decisive questions. What does it take for the ambulance services to disclose their figures to the project, and therefore to the accident insurers as well? Which requirements matter, and which conditions have to be met for that to actually happen? That was certainly one of the central questions.

What resistance or reservations did you expect?

For the dialogue itself, I did not expect resistance, at most a lack of interest or a lack of time. We noticed that when we had to follow up so that the dialogue could really pick up speed. I don’t think there is resistance when people are able to contribute to a topic. When the whole thing is designed efficiently, as it was with BrainE4, it is easier to motivate people.

How have you previously gauged the attitudes and concerns of a sector?

I have never done it this thoroughly in my previous projects. We always try to work in a grassroots, democratic way. Usually this happens in steering and working groups that include people from the front line. But even then, only individual representatives with their own particular interests sit at the table. They do reflect a certain part of the sector, but they also question or challenge your own expertise. We had never done it in a way that gives everyone the chance to express themselves and contribute. Often, as an interim step, you check through a formal consultation or stakeholder consultation whether you are on the right track. You also keep going back to the members concerned, typically with surveys: We are heading in this direction, do you think that is right too? That is the more traditional approach.

How did you come across BrainE4, and what convinced you about the idea duel to take this different route?

At first I didn’t even know this route existed. We were looking for a partner for the data collection and worked with OST, the Eastern Switzerland University of Applied Sciences. OST had apparently already worked with BrainE4 in other areas and brought the method into our project as a first step. That is how we got to know each other, and I was very curious about this method. I wanted to see first-hand whether it worked as efficiently as it had been explained to us.
1/3
Interverband für Rettungswesen logo

Were the promises and announcements kept?

Yes. Even the preparation was very efficient. We held a workshop of around three hours with a fairly large group of six to eight people. There was even someone who could interpret simultaneously when needed. In this workshop, we sharpened the hypotheses that had been prepared beforehand and jointly captured possible answers. Afterwards, we briefly circulated it among the workshop participants for comment. I then had nothing more to do with running the dialogue itself. And the report at the end is excellent and very clear. You can go into depth, but you also see quickly what is relevant. It is very well prepared. And if you are unsure, you can still go deeper and see what else is there.
«With BrainE4, and thanks to it, we were able to bring every organisation on board.»

You achieved a participation rate of around 70 percent. How do you rate that figure, especially on such a sensitive topic?

Of course I think it’s great. More important to me is that as many ambulance services as possible really contribute, share their concerns and pass on the points that matter to them for the project. Such a high rate shows that people could contribute with little effort. You don’t have to spend an hour filling in a survey. You can go in, do an idea duel, leave, and come back a week later. The format was new, which was certainly a plus, but above all people were able to raise their concerns very efficiently.

Those who took part played around 130 idea duels on average. How do you rate the sector’s willingness to get involved?

The willingness was very high. You can see that these issues matter to the sector. In the end it is about money, about revenue and the economic viability of an ambulance service. That interests the head of an ambulance service just as much as the person responsible for finance.

Was there any feedback during the dialogue?

Yes, there was. Because the format was new, we noticed that not everyone had fully understood how it works. We held a kick-off webinar at the start that everyone could attend, and it was recorded so people could watch it later. Later we sent a reminder and shared short explainer videos from BrainE4 so that people understood how to contribute. It is new for most people, and you have to explain it well at the start. That was a lesson for us from the project.

Was there a moment along the way when you thought: this actually works?

Yes, right at the start, when there was a first wave with high participation. I was pleasantly surprised. Then participation began to stall, and we followed up. We drew people’s attention to it again and explained exactly how the tool and the dialogue work. After that there was another big second wave. That is when I saw: now it is working, now people are getting involved, now the right idea duels and the right messages are coming through. That gave us a solid basis for the further work.

Which insight from the report made you think the most?

To be honest, none. Everything came up that I already knew. The report confirmed what we know anyway from the many projects in this field. Nothing surprised me. It really confirmed what you assume and know. That is good, because it means you are on the safe side: you know that this is roughly what people think, and what I think too, and you can see where we need to be careful and where we face challenges. The important thing was the confirmation: the dialogue confirmed what we had assumed. On top of that, we have made sure on a solid footing that our project is on the right track.

Besides confirmation, prioritisation is often decisive. Did anything surprise you there?

Not there either. I did not look at every part of the report, but for all the important points I went through, nothing surprised me.

Surveys like this also raise expectations. How do you deal with that?

When you ask people what they would like, you naturally raise certain expectations. That is why, in our communication, we always tried to make it clear: we will take the concerns on board, but in the end we are negotiating. And negotiating always means give and take. We cannot only pursue our own goals and wishes. On the other side of the table are the insurers, who also have their own goals and wishes in this project.
«It confirmed what we had assumed.»

What did the decision matrix show you that a conventional survey cannot?

With such density, it shows a great deal of important information at once. With surveys, you usually have to invest many hours before you find out what really matters. Here I had the feeling that you could grasp very quickly what concerns the people in charge of the ambulance services, what wishes and needs they have and what conditions they expect. That is extremely helpful.
2/3
Interverband für Rettungswesen logo

How did you find the report and the decision matrix?

The report and the decision matrix are very concisely structured and very well written. You can extract the important information very efficiently and go deeper if you want to understand certain elements in more detail. The whole thing is so well structured that you find the essentials quickly and easily.

How did you report the results back to the ambulance services?

We reported them back in full, with a short comment, mainly on the next steps in the project. We disclosed the entire report to everyone so they could look at it themselves and there was full transparency about what had been gathered. Now, together with OST, we are moving into the detailed design of the data collection. We will keep involving the ambulance services, because they are all part of the data collection anyway.

How did you experience working with BrainE4? What went well, and what would you have liked to be different?

The collaboration was very efficient, extremely clear and well planned. What we were told at the beginning was delivered: the effort on our side was very small, and at the end we received a concise report. We had to organise and prepare the kick-off webinar, but the path was clear, and we were always properly provided with all the information we needed. Work went on in the background, and all deadlines and dates were met. It worked absolutely perfectly and was very professional.

Is there anything you would do differently next time?

Just one thing: at the start, we did not explain well enough how exactly the dialogue works. Input from BrainE4 would have helped there, for example a recommendation to show this or that in the webinar or to play a particular video. Then people would have understood it better from the outset. We missed that. Perhaps we as the project team also did not communicate it well enough.

How much effort did it take compared with a conventional approach? Can you estimate what it would have cost to gauge the sector’s attitudes the traditional way?

It would certainly have taken considerably more effort. I really can’t put a figure on it, that is difficult. But because the method is so well established and BrainE4 has a clear, efficient approach, you don’t have to worry about how to design the questionnaire so that it isn’t leading, or how to evaluate all the many questions. You can do a lot the traditional way today too, but it would have meant considerably more effort. For me it was very efficient.

How do you rate the value for money?

When I compare the financial side and the effort involved, it is a very efficient and fair process. Given the innovation behind this process and this dialogue, and given the work that goes into every single dialogue, I find the price fair, as far as I can judge. It lets you reach members or organisations very quickly and with little effort, and at the end you have what you need. In my view, the price tag for this method is right.
«An efficient way of involving the people affected.»

What is your conclusion?

My conclusion is that BrainE4’s method manages to capture the opinions, attitudes and needs of a large group of people or organisations very efficiently, and to prepare them in a way we can work with. In many projects we tried to involve those affected through working groups and sounding boards, but we never managed to give everyone the opportunity to contribute. This time we did. With BrainE4, and thanks to it, we were able to bring every organisation on board. They were able to put forward their needs, and we are taking them forward. I have got to know a new process that works very well and can be used in a wide range of contexts. I also work a lot in healthcare, where political issues keep coming up. There, it could be used to shape opinion very efficiently. My experience of the idea duel was very positive, and I am pleasantly surprised by this dialogue and by the ideas it can generate.

Who would you recommend BrainE4 to?

I probably already have, but I will certainly do so again. I will definitely put it forward at my former employer, the national hospital association, because I still have contacts there. I am also more active again in the cantonal hospital association in the Canton of Bern, and something could be done there too. It always depends on how many people you need to reach. I would most likely recommend it to associations, because that is where most of my work is. It can be used particularly well wherever you repeatedly need to reach a larger number of members.
«In my view, the price tag for this method is right.»

If you had to say in one sentence why an association or a public authority should use BrainE4, what would that sentence be?

An efficient way of involving the people affected.
Online Dialogue:
71
 
Interviews
159
 
ideas and arguments
9,222
 
idea duels
Contact:
Christoph Schöni
Managing Director, sanasolutio GmbH
Tel: +41 78 737 76 89
Mail: christoph.schoeni@sanasolutio.ch
Interview: thk
3/3
20 minutes by video. No obligation.

What is your topic?